Global Learning
  • Home
  • Defenders of Cuban Socialism
    • UN Charter
    • Declaration of Human Rights
    • Bandung
    • New International Economic Order
    • Non-Aligned Movement
  • Substack editorial column
  • New Cold War articles
  • Friends of Socialist China articles
  • Global Research articles
  • Counterpunch articles
  • Cuba and the world-system
    • Table of Contents and chapter summaries
    • About the author
    • Endorsements
    • Obtaining your copy
  • Blog ¨The View from the South¨
    • Blog Index
    • Posts in reverse chronological order
  • The Voice of Third World Leaders
    • Asia >
      • Ho Chi Minh
      • Xi Jinping, President of China
    • Africa >
      • Kwame Nkrumah
      • Julius Nyerere
    • Latin America >
      • Fidel Castro
      • Hugo Chávez
      • Raúl Castro >
        • 55th anniversary speech, January 1, 1914
        • Opening Speech, CELAC
        • Address at G-77, June 15, 2014
        • Address to National Assembly, July 5, 2014
        • Address to National Assembly, December 20, 2014
        • Speech on Venezuela at ALBA, 3-17-2015
        • Declaration of December 18, 2015 on USA-Cuba relations
        • Speech at ALBA, March 5, 2018
      • Miguel Díaz-Canel >
        • UN address, September 26, 2018
        • 100th annivesary, CP of China
      • Evo Morales >
        • About Evo Morales
        • Address to G-77 plus China, January 8, 2014
        • Address to UN General Assembly, September 24, 2014
      • Rafael Correa >
        • About Rafael Correa
        • Speech at CELAC 1/29/2015
        • Speech at Summit of the Americas 2015
      • Nicolás Maduro
      • Cristina Fernández
      • Cuban Ministry of Foreign Relations >
        • Statement at re-opening of Cuban Embassy in USA, June 20, 2015
        • The visit of Barack Obama to Cuba
        • Declaration on parliamentary coup in Brazil, August 31, 2016
        • Declaration of the Revolutionary Government of Cuba on Venezuela, April 13, 2019
      • ALBA >
        • Declaration of ALBA Political Council, May 21, 2019
        • Declaration on Venezuela, March 17, 2015
        • Declaration on Venezuela, April 10, 2017
      • Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC) >
        • Havana Declaration 2014
        • Declaration on Venezuela, March 26
    • Martin Luther King, Jr.
    • International >
      • Peoples’ Summit 2015
      • The Group of 77 >
        • Declaration on a New World Order 2014
        • Declaration on Venezuela 3/26/2015
      • BRICS
      • Non-Aligned Movement
  • Readings
    • Charles McKelvey, Cuba in Global Context
    • Piero Gleijeses, Cuba and Africa
    • Charles McKelvey, Chávez and the Revolution in Venezuela
    • Charles McKelvey, The unfinished agenda of race in USA
    • Charles McKelvey, Marxist-Leninist-Fidelist-Chavist Revolutionary
  • Recommended Books
  • Contact

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Recommended books on Amazon.com; click on image of book to connect

Reform from above; reform from below

8/21/2014

0 Comments

 
Posted August 27, 2014

      When I was a young man encountering the student anti-war and black power movements at Penn State from 1965 to 1969, I thought that reform was a good thing, for it made changes for the good of the people.  We young radical students understood in a general sense that there was a difference between reform and revolution: revolution involves fundamental structural change and a change in who exercises power; reform involves significant changes, but it does not change fundamental structures or who governs.  Revolutionaries, we thought, were antagonistic to reform because they wanted to change things more deeply and more quickly.  However, during twenty years of listening to Cuban revolutionaries, I have come to understand that revolutionaries are against reform not only because it is not fundamental and does not change who governs.  But also because it often has a cynical and sinister character, formulated from above with the deliberate intention of braking the revolution from below. 

     So let us distinguish reform from below and reform from above.  Reform from below seeks to improve the conditions of the people, and it places no limits on these improvements, and they can include changes in structures and in who governs.  When reform from below accepts limited changes, it does so because of its perception of what is possible, taking into account the existing arrangement of political forces.  Reform from below accepts changes that do not touch structures or power, not because it is fully satisfied, but because it believes that nothing more is politically possible at the moment; if it were possible, reform from below would want deeper changes. 

     In contrast, reform from above does not want deeper changes in structure and power.  Reform from above wants to maintain the established structures and the prevailing distribution of power in the established economic-political-social system.  Therefore, reform from above seeks to undercut the popular movement, by offering significant concessions that do not change structures or power.  When reform from above has success, some of the people are seduced and confused by its maneuvers, and divisions in the popular movement occur, weakening its force.

     We have seen important examples of reform from above in the political careers of Ramón Grau and Carlos Prío, who were the presidents of the Cuban neocolonial republic from 1944-48 and 1948-52, respectively.  They pretended to be inheritors of a revolutionary tradition that dated backed to 1868, but their legacy was to deliver eight years of unprecedented corruption, dashing the hopes of a people that was seeking to develop a more just and dignified nation, in accordance with the dreams of Martí (“The failure of ‘democracy,’ 1940-52” 8/25/2014).

      The difference between reform from above and reform from below can be difficult to see in practice, because both include concrete measures designed to increase the level of education, health and housing of the people.  The difference can be discerned when we observe the packages of which these measures are part.  The reform from above package includes no specific measures that adversely affect the interests of the ruling elite; it sometime pretends to be opposed to elite interests, but careful analysis reveals that its measures are superficial or full of loopholes.  Reform from above sees specific measures in defense of popular interests as having satisfied the demands of the people, and it often turns to repression of the popular organizations that push for more changes.  In contrast, the reform from below package sees the specific measures in defense of popular interests as small but important steps in the empowerment of the people in a process that could lead to fundamental structural change.  For reform from below, the specific measures are most important not in the needs that they satisfy, but in teaching the people the power that they possess, if they act collectively. 

     Reform from above is cynical, for it pretends to be revolutionary, when it is not.  And it is pernicious, because it confuses and divides the people, thus weakening the revolutionary movement.  In moments of crisis, reform from above often allies with the reactionary sector of the bourgeoisie or with fascism.

     Whereas reform from above is cynical and pernicious, reform from below has good intentions.  But it is wrong-headed.  Although reform from below sees itself as part of the revolution and always is opposed to the oppression of the revolution, it is not revolutionary.  It mistakenly believes that fundamental structural change and the taking of power by the people are not possible.  It lacks revolutionary faith, a belief that the people through united action, rooted in understanding, can take power and establish an alternative political-economic-social system. Lacking the clearly-defined goal of the taking of power by the people, reform from below often allies with reform from above in important moments of confrontation, undermining the popular revolution when it stands ready to take power.  Reform from below lacks the clear understanding and revolutionary faith that are necessary for the taking of decisive steps at critical moments.   

     On a global scale, reform from above has been tried on various occasions: the New Deal and Keynesian economics, the Good Neighbor policy of FDR, the important-substitution project of the Latin American urban and industrial national bourgeoisie, the Alliance for Progress of Kennedy, and the Human Rights policy of Jimmy Carter (see “Imperialism and the FDR New Deal” 9/20/2013; “The Alliance for Progress” 9/26/2013; “Jimmy Carter” 10/1/2013).  FDR’s reformist vision of a peaceful neocolonial world-system characterized by cooperation among the global powers and significant concessions to newly-independent governments of Africa and Asia as well as to Latin American governments was not implemented following the death of FDR, as it was cast aside by the ideology of the Cold War (see “Post-war militarization of economy & society” 9/23/2014).  These examples of reform from above are all characterized by the making of concession to the popular sectors without undermining the interests of the elite. 

    But reform from above on a global scale is not workable.  The structures of the world-system are designed to super-exploit the workers and peasants of the peripheral and semi-peripheral zones, generating profits for the elite and a higher standing of living for the working and middle classes of the core.  The concessions that can be made to the superexploited global masses, without affecting the benefits to the core, are necessarily limited, and they will not be enough to politically satisfy the global masses and establish global political stability, particularly in a time in which the world-system has reached the geographical limits of the earth, reducing its capacity to expand.  Reform of the neocolonial world-system is not possible.  A stable world-system can be developed only on a foundation of structures that respect the social and economic rights of all persons and the sovereignty of all nations.  This requires not the reform of neocolonialism, but its abolition.

      With the historically demonstrated failure of the reform of the world-system from above, and with the devastating consequences of the turn of the global powers to a neoliberal economic war against the poor and to imperialist militarism, a global popular revolution has emerged in our time.  It is constituted by an alliance, on a global scale, between reform from below and revolution.  It seeks to construct an alternative, more just, democratic and sustainable world-system, in which neocolonialism would be eradicated, for its structures would defend the sovereignty and true independence of all nations.
      

Key words:  Third World, revolution, colonialism, neocolonialism, imperialism, democracy, national liberation, sovereignty, self-determination, socialism, Marxism, Leninism, Cuba, Latin America, world-system, world-economy, development, underdevelopment, colonial, neocolonial, blog Third World perspective, Cuban Revolution, neocolonial republic, Grau, reformism
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author: Charles McKelvey

    Retired professor, writer,  and Marxist-Leninist-Fidelist-Chavist revolutionary

    Categories

    All
    American Revolution
    Blog Index
    Bolivia
    Charismatic Leaders
    China
    Critique Of The Left
    Cuban History
    Cuba Today
    Ecuador
    Environment
    French Revolution
    Gay Rights
    Haitian Revolution
    Knowledge
    Latin American History
    Latin American Right
    Latin American Unity
    Marx
    Marxism-Leninism
    Mexican Revolution
    Miscellaneous
    Neocolonialism
    Neoliberalism
    Nicaragua
    North-South Cooperation
    Presidential Elections 2016
    Press
    Public Debate In USA
    Race
    Religion And Revolution
    Revolution
    Russian Revolution
    South-South Cooperation
    Third World
    Trump
    US Ascent
    US Imperialism
    Vanguard
    Venezuela
    Vietnam
    Wallerstein
    Women And Revolution
    World History
    World-System
    World-System Crisis

    Archives

    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    January 2013

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

More Ads


website by Sierra Creation