Global Learning
  • Home
  • Defenders of Cuban Socialism
    • UN Charter
    • Declaration of Human Rights
    • Bandung
    • New International Economic Order
    • Non-Aligned Movement
  • Substack editorial column
  • New Cold War articles
  • Friends of Socialist China articles
  • Global Research articles
  • Counterpunch articles
  • Cuba and the world-system
    • Table of Contents and chapter summaries
    • About the author
    • Endorsements
    • Obtaining your copy
  • Blog ¨The View from the South¨
    • Blog Index
    • Posts in reverse chronological order
  • The Voice of Third World Leaders
    • Asia >
      • Ho Chi Minh
      • Xi Jinping, President of China
    • Africa >
      • Kwame Nkrumah
      • Julius Nyerere
    • Latin America >
      • Fidel Castro
      • Hugo Chávez
      • Raúl Castro >
        • 55th anniversary speech, January 1, 1914
        • Opening Speech, CELAC
        • Address at G-77, June 15, 2014
        • Address to National Assembly, July 5, 2014
        • Address to National Assembly, December 20, 2014
        • Speech on Venezuela at ALBA, 3-17-2015
        • Declaration of December 18, 2015 on USA-Cuba relations
        • Speech at ALBA, March 5, 2018
      • Miguel Díaz-Canel >
        • UN address, September 26, 2018
        • 100th annivesary, CP of China
      • Evo Morales >
        • About Evo Morales
        • Address to G-77 plus China, January 8, 2014
        • Address to UN General Assembly, September 24, 2014
      • Rafael Correa >
        • About Rafael Correa
        • Speech at CELAC 1/29/2015
        • Speech at Summit of the Americas 2015
      • Nicolás Maduro
      • Cristina Fernández
      • Cuban Ministry of Foreign Relations >
        • Statement at re-opening of Cuban Embassy in USA, June 20, 2015
        • The visit of Barack Obama to Cuba
        • Declaration on parliamentary coup in Brazil, August 31, 2016
        • Declaration of the Revolutionary Government of Cuba on Venezuela, April 13, 2019
      • ALBA >
        • Declaration of ALBA Political Council, May 21, 2019
        • Declaration on Venezuela, March 17, 2015
        • Declaration on Venezuela, April 10, 2017
      • Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC) >
        • Havana Declaration 2014
        • Declaration on Venezuela, March 26
    • Martin Luther King, Jr.
    • International >
      • Peoples’ Summit 2015
      • The Group of 77 >
        • Declaration on a New World Order 2014
        • Declaration on Venezuela 3/26/2015
      • BRICS
      • Non-Aligned Movement
  • Readings
    • Charles McKelvey, Cuba in Global Context
    • Piero Gleijeses, Cuba and Africa
    • Charles McKelvey, Chávez and the Revolution in Venezuela
    • Charles McKelvey, The unfinished agenda of race in USA
    • Charles McKelvey, Marxist-Leninist-Fidelist-Chavist Revolutionary
  • Recommended Books
  • Contact

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Recommended books on Amazon.com; click on image of book to connect

Herbert Marcuse Revisited

5/10/2016

0 Comments

 
Posted May 12, 2016

     I continue with reflection on Mitchel Cohen’s 2013 book, What is Direct Action? Reframing Revolutionary Strategy in Light of Occupy Wall Street, and I focus today on Mitchel’s criticisms of Herbert Marcuse’s 1964 book, One-Dimensional Man.  The book was frequently mentioned, although not necessarily read, during the student anti-war movement of the late 1960s.  There were commemorations on the fiftieth anniversary of the book, so it can be considered a classic. 

     Mitchel interprets Herbert Marcuse as maintaining that capitalism, by the middle of the twentieth century, had undermined entirely the capacity for revolutionary consciousness to emerge, inasmuch as it had arrived to a stage in which it was able to manufacture a desire for commodities, creating what Marcuse calls “false needs.”  Mitchel finds Marcuse’s position to be overly pessimistic, for it concludes that the working class in Western Europe and the United States is not revolutionary and has become part of a “labor aristocracy” that itself exploits (Cohen 2013:60-63).  In my view, Mitchel does not appreciate that Marcuse was insightfully identifying important emerging tendencies in the core nations of the capitalist world-economy.

      Marcuse, along with Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno and Jurgen Habermas, was one of the prominent members of the Institute for Social Research in Frankfurt, Germany, even though Marcuse did not return to Frankfurt from exile in the United States following World War II, as did Horkheimer and Adorno (Jay 1973).  The strengths and limitations of the analysis of the Frankfurt School reflect their social location in Western Europe and the United States, at a time in which a consumer society had emerged, the labor movement had become bureaucratized, and the intellectuals of the West were not integrally tied to the twentieth century movements of social and national liberation in the Third World.

      The bureaucratization of the proletarian revolution, and its incorporation into a structure of reform from above, was a dimension of a general twentieth century social phenomenon of bureaucratization.  In Russia, the bureaucratization of the proletarian revolution expressed itself in the form of a petty bourgeois counterrevolution, culminating in Stalinism; in Western Europe, in the form of social democratic political parties that were major parties, often in control of the state bureaucracy; and in the United States, in the form of the New Deal social contract and its corresponding structures of labor-management relations.

     In Western Europe and the United States, the bureaucratization of the labor movement and its accommodation to bourgeois democratic parliamentarianism and reform established a tendency toward the conversion of the upper levels of the working class into a kind of petty bourgeoisie, able to consume the multiple products of the consumer society.  At the same time, with an increase in educational opportunity, many of the worker’s sons and daughters entered into middle class professions, thus increasing the size of the middle class and reducing the working class, and decreasing the influence of labor unions and political parties supported by workers.  The increasingly higher standard of living of the working and middles classes in the core was made possible by the colonial and neocolonial superexploitation of the Third World, which reached its ecological and political limits beginning in the 1960s; and by government deficit spending, which would reach its financial limits in the 1970s.

      The containment of the labor movement in conjunction with the emergence of a consumer society provided a social base from which the Frankfurt School was able formulate a penetrating critique of the culture of capitalism.  The Frankfort School described the eclipse of reason in the twentieth century, making impossible the defense of values and reasonable ends and goals.  It analyzed the creation of false needs through advertising, establishing the foundation for the consumer society.  And it maintained that there is a universal human interest in liberation.  In accordance with this interest in liberation, Marcuse proposed the formation of a “transcendent historical project” that could challenge the established historical project; and Habermas envisioned a “communication community,” consisting of representatives of various particular interests who would seek consensus through dialogue in an environment free of coercion (Horkheimer 1972, 1974; Horkheimer and Adorno 1972; Marcuse 1960, 1964; Habermas 1970, 1971, 1973, 1975). 

     However, the penetrating insights of the Frankford school could not indicate the way toward human liberation, because the formulations of the Frankfort School were not connected to any revolutionary social movement, neither to the classical workers’ movement in Europe, which had become bureaucratized and reformist; nor to the Third World revolutionary movements, which pertained to another social world.  Marcuse was loosely connected to the student anti-war movement and the youth rebellions of the 1960s, but his concept of a transcendent historical project was not based on analysis of what the members of the movement were doing.  Moreover, the student/anti-war movement was not able to sustain itself as a relatively permanent social movement, which would have provided the foundation for a more complete formulation in theory and practice of Marcuse’s concept of a transcendent historical project.   Similarly, Habermas’ concept of a communication community was idealist, for the conditions for dialogue free of coercion do not exist in capitalist society.

      Nevertheless, in spite of their limitations, Marcuse and the Frankfurt School formulated penetrating insights into the structures of domination of the capitalist world-system, insights necessary for discerning the road to human liberation.


​References

Cohen, Mitchel, et.al.  2013.  What is Direct Action?  Reframing Revolutionary Strategy in Light of Occupy Wall Street.  Brooklyn: Red Balloon Collective Publications.

Horkheimer, Max.  1972.  Critical Theory. New York:  Herder and Herder.
 
__________.  1974.  Eclipse of Reason. New York:  Seabury Press.
 
Horkheimer, Max and Theodor W. Adorno.  1972.  Dialect of Enlightenment. New York:  The Seabury Press, A Continuum Book.
 
Marcuse, Herbert.  1960.  Reason and Revolution. Boston:  Beacon Press.
 
__________.  1964.  One-Dimensional Man. Boston: Beacon Press.
 
Habermas, Jurgen.  1970.  Toward a Rational Society.  Boston:  Beacon Press.
 
__________.  1971.  Knowledge and Human Interest.  Boston: Beacon Press
 
__________.  1973.  Theory and Practice.  Boston: Beacon Press.
 
__________.  1975.  Legitimation Crisis.  Boston:  Beacon Press.
 
Jay, Martin.  1973.  The Dialectical Imagination:  A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute for Social Research, 1923-50. Boston: Little, Brown, and Co. 
 
 
Key words:  Marcuse, Frankfurt School, false needs, transcendent historical project, communication community

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author: Charles McKelvey

    Retired professor, writer,  and Marxist-Leninist-Fidelist-Chavist revolutionary

    Categories

    All
    American Revolution
    Blog Index
    Bolivia
    Charismatic Leaders
    China
    Critique Of The Left
    Cuban History
    Cuba Today
    Ecuador
    Environment
    French Revolution
    Gay Rights
    Haitian Revolution
    Knowledge
    Latin American History
    Latin American Right
    Latin American Unity
    Marx
    Marxism-Leninism
    Mexican Revolution
    Miscellaneous
    Neocolonialism
    Neoliberalism
    Nicaragua
    North-South Cooperation
    Presidential Elections 2016
    Press
    Public Debate In USA
    Race
    Religion And Revolution
    Revolution
    Russian Revolution
    South-South Cooperation
    Third World
    Trump
    US Ascent
    US Imperialism
    Vanguard
    Venezuela
    Vietnam
    Wallerstein
    Women And Revolution
    World History
    World-System
    World-System Crisis

    Archives

    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    January 2013

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

More Ads


website by Sierra Creation